Why didn t serfdom work in russia?

11
Mason Casper asked a question: Why didn t serfdom work in russia?
Asked By: Mason Casper
Date created: Wed, Jan 27, 2021 5:48 AM
Date updated: Fri, Jul 8, 2022 4:14 AM

Content

Top best answers to the question «Why didn t serfdom work in russia»

  • Serfdom was hardly efficient; serfs and nobles had little incentive to improve the land. However, it was politically effective. Nobles rarely challenged the tsar for fear of provoking a peasant uprising. Serfs were often given lifelong tenancy on their plots, so they tended to be conservative as well.

10 other answers

Trade couldn’t be stopped, although the ban on selling serfs without land was repeated in 1833 and then again in 1842; but it remained so until the end of serfdom.

As a whole, serfdom both came and remained in Russia much later than in other European countries. Slavery remained a legally recognized institution in Russia until 1723, when Peter the Great abolished slavery and converted the slaves into serfs. This was relevant more to household slaves because Russian agricultural slaves were formally converted into serfs earlier in 1679.

Soviet history textbooks said serfdom should have been abolished because it hindered economic growth, as free peasants would work better. Unfortunately, this isn’t true.

Serfdom was manifestly not working. It had failed to provide the calibre of soldier Russia needed. So it was that in 1856, the second year of his reign, Alexander II (1855- 81) announced to the nobles of Russia that ‘the existing condition of owning souls cannot remained unchanged.

Russia was hesistant to let go of the serfdom system because it would allow the serfs to have much more freedom and possibly revolt. Not that revolts didn't happen because they did during this time like Pugachev's Rebellion. Overall, Russia had always been a nation that was late to the game in comparison to Western Europe.

Serfdom in Russia was very much like serfdom in the Polish-Lithuanian Confederation, but it developed and ended later in Russia than it did in Poland. Serfs were tied to the land, expected to work a specific number of days for the landlord and allowed to farm some land for themselves. Serfdom in Russia, as in Poland, was not connected to feudalism.

At the same time when Russians got a serfdom or hight tax. Therefore all this conquests were from the account of ordinary russians. In medieval time Westerns had a feudalism but Russians had a democracy. Right after Westerns abolished a serfdom in their own counties, they imposed serfdom on Russians. Russians didn't like it, they protest it obviously.

If historians talk about the abolition of serfdom in 1861, it had a revival in 1932-1937, when peasants were banned from leaving the kolkhoz they were assigned to. The economic downfall Rudolf ...

Catherine the Great considered herself an enlightened monarch. She toyed with the idea of curbing some of the excesses of serfdom in Russia. The reaction of the nobility to these gentle hints convinced Catherine that the security of her throne depended on dropping any attempt to interfere with serfdom.

Why was serfdom so expensive for Russia? -in order to train as a soldier had to be conscripted -no longer a serf, to prevent them from returning home this was for 25 years

Your Answer