Why norwegian socialism doesnt work in the usa?

Jon Medhurst asked a question: Why norwegian socialism doesnt work in the usa?
Asked By: Jon Medhurst
Date created: Sun, Mar 28, 2021 8:29 PM

Content

FAQ

Those who are looking for an answer to the question «Why norwegian socialism doesnt work in the usa?» often ask the following questions:

đź’» How could socialism work?

Basically socialism is about matching investment of society’s resources with human need. Two essentials to organise this are, 1) a system of democratic planning on a local, regional and international level and 2) public ownership of the economy, such that the major corporations that dominate the economy are displaced.

đź’» Can socialism work in usa?

Democracy for America Communications Director Neil Sroka argues socialism would be better for Americans.

đź’» Did socialism in cuba work?

The short answer is NO, Cuba is not proof that socialism does or does not work. A single data point influenced by many factors says very very little about it's political/economic systems. To be fair here, let us consider a number of other questions... - Isn't Denmark proof that socialism does work?

10 other answers

They do not. First, they are not socialism. They are actually capitalist, and that is why everything they do is working. Sure, the state may own a gigantic percentage of the means of production, and have “large public sectors, strong job protections, and labor markets governed by centralized union contract.”.

1) The Nordic system kills innovation, and the United States’ adopting it would have dire consequences for the world economy. As Daron Acemoglu, an eminent economist at MIT, wrote in 2013:

Reason.com managing editor Peter Suderman discusses how socialism has hurt Venezuela and why it won’t work in the U.S.

The reason people in America think that Norway is socialist is because, for decades, conservatism has been calling the things that Norway has “socialist”. Things like medicare for all, a functional justice system, an effective government, wealth redistribution policies, etc.

Originally Answered: Why doesnt socialism work in America? One reason is because of geographic size and the distribution of our population over a large area. In a genuine democracy, elected officials (i.e., those who would administer a socialist state) are accountable to citizens.

Overall, it is clear that the Scandinavian countries are not in fact archetypes of successful democratic socialism. Sanders has convinced a great deal of people that socialism is something it is not, and he has used the Scandinavian countries to prove its efficacy while ignoring the many ways they deviate, sometimes dramatically, from what Sanders himself advocates.

Socially, however, the picture is much worse: America ranks in the mid-teens for happiest countries, while its life expectancy is two years behind Norway, and actually fell in 2016 and 2017.

Scandinavian countries—specifically, Norway, Sweden, Denmark, and Finland—are perceived as socialist because their citizens pay very high income taxes.

This is a significant reason why so many so-called “socialist” and “communist” regimes throughout the world end up resorting to violence, because without violence, threats to remove liberty, etc., there’s simply no reason for people to freely choose to work at an efficient rate.

The United States has 318 million people while Norway (5.1 million), Denmark (5.6 million), and Sweden (9.7 million) all have only a small fraction of our population. The same ideology and policies won’t work in all countries. Socialism by the concept is immoral in the sense of stealing other people’s money and using it for what you want.

Your Answer

We've handpicked 22 related questions for you, similar to «Why norwegian socialism doesnt work in the usa?» so you can surely find the answer!

Will socialism work in usa?

There is a very real possibility that the United States may be dominated by those favoring socialism as early as this coming January. If that occurs, the proclivity of those hard-left officeholders...

Read more

Can democratic socialism work in america?

Pure Socialism Not for America In theory, pure socialism sounds like an ideal system in which no one would exploit another person and everyone would be equal. However, this system has been tried...

Read more

Does socialism like in denmark work?

Danes actually pay for their brand of socialism through heavy taxation. In Denmark, everyone pays at least the 25% value-added tax (VAT) on all purchases. Income tax rates are high. If you receive...

Read more

Does socialism work in germany now?

Times that socialism has worked. Yes, Socialism has worked. If you look at attempts at socialism, Most of them were successful and had great standards of living. Let me dispel any stereotypes you hold. . . No, The soviet union, China (or their satilight states) were not socialist.

Read more

Does socialism work in germany today?

A few weeks back I got an email with the question: “What is it about Germany that seems to make socialism work?” Not due to socialism, but thanks to Ludwig Erhard’s radical pro-market reforms, the modest monetary policy by the Bundesbank over decades, the internal devaluation of the 1990s, and the reforms of Gerhard Schröder and the Social Democrats in 2004, Germany is successful today.

Read more

Does socialism work in the netherlands?

I wasn’t going to try to answer this question until I saw some doofus write, “Socialism doesn't work anywhere, ever.” The short answer is “Yes, if you consider the Netherlands a workable nation.” I think the Netherlands is a nation workting pretty...

Read more

How does socialism work in cuba?

Bigotry and hate speech will be met with immediate bans; socialism is an intrinsically inclusive system and bigotry is oppressive, exclusionary, and not conducive to a healthy and productive learning space.

Read more

How does socialism work in denmark?

Danes actually pay for their brand of socialism through heavy taxation. In Denmark, everyone pays at least the 25% value-added tax (VAT) on all purchases. Income tax rates are high.

Read more

How does socialism work in france?

Well, historically, the birth of socialism itself can be traced back to post-French Revolution political theorists like François- Noël Babeuf They promoted economic equality and the right for workers to share in the profits of their production But France’s current socialist policies were mostly introduced by their longest sitting president, Francois Mitterrand He was in office from 1981 to 1995

Read more

How does socialism work in netherlands?

Overview. Socialism came relatively late to the Netherlands, because of its slow industrialization. In the 1860s a socialist movement began to develop. Although the socialists were aided by the foundation of the First International and of the first Dutch trade unions, united in the Algemeen Nederlands Werklieden Vereniging, a socialist party ...

Read more

How does socialism work in norway?

Norway is unquestionably more socialist than Venezuela… Indeed, it is considerably more socialist than supposedly-communist China. This is absurdly inaccurate. If there was a thermonuclear version of wrong, you would be seeing a giant mushroom cloud. Here’s the data on overall economic freedom for Norway, Venezuela, and China. As you can see, Norway is far more market-oriented.

Read more

How does socialism work in venezuela?

The U.S. media portray Venezuela as an oil-rich country that fell into the hands of a communist-style dictatorship allied with the Castro regime in Cuba. They link the horrible and indefensible...

Read more

How does socialism work in vietnam?

Your assumption is not correct, Socialism is worked for Vietnam and many countries like China, Laos, and Cuba. Socialism is one of stage before Communism and after Capitalism where the capitalist and communist economies can exist and support each ...

Read more

Why didn't socialism work in italy?

Socialism Didn’t Work In Sweden, And It Won’t Work In America Bernie Sanders and AOC point to the brief window of Swedish socialism’s artificial success before Sweden crumbled under its reality.

Read more

Why does socialism work in denmark?

Socialism does not exist in Denmark or Norway. They are social democracies. How and why the two are confused is a reflection of the gullibility to people to believe the BS from places like FOXCN, Alex Jones, Rush Limbaugh and the like. They incorporate it into their scare tactics to illicit confidence in their propaganda.

Read more

Why does socialism work in france?

How Socialism Works In France ... strengthened workers' rights, increased taxation on the wealthy and implemented France's famous 35-hour work week. RELATED: Why France Is Turning Against Its ...

Read more

Why does socialism work in norway?

It is certainly true that Sweden, Norway, Finland, and Denmark are notable economic successes. What is false is that these countries are particularly socialist.

Read more

Why doesn’t socialism work in america?

The United States has 318 million people while Norway (5.1 million), Denmark (5.6 million), and Sweden (9.7 million) all have only a small fraction of our population. The same ideology and policies won’t work in all countries. Socialism by the concept is immoral in the sense of stealing other people’s money and using it for what you want.

Read more

Will socialism work in south africa?

Socialism is failing in South Africa already. The ANC government was suckled on the teat of communism and has allowed the South African Communist Party undue influence over governments policy for the past 2 decades. As a compromise between different factions they have implemented numerous socialist policies.

Read more

Would socialism work in south africa?

Socialism is failing in South Africa already. The ANC government was suckled on the teat of communism and has allowed the South African Communist Party undue influence over governments policy for the past 2 decades.

Read more

Does socialism work in germany right now?

A few weeks back I got an email with the question: “What is it about Germany that seems to make socialism work?” Not due to socialism, but thanks to Ludwig Erhard’s radical pro-market reforms, the modest monetary policy by the Bundesbank over decades, the internal devaluation of the 1990s, and the reforms of Gerhard Schröder and the Social Democrats in 2004, Germany is successful today.

Read more

How does socialism work in simple terms?

Socialism is a system that shares economic output equally throughout the population. It values the collective well-being of the community, rather than individuals. The government distributes resources, giving it greater control over its citizens.

Read more